Saturday, January 18, 2014

Totally Random Thoughts on Intuition


What if...

  • Ordinary usage of the term “intuition” includes more than the extension of the term. Psychological research seems similarly permissive. 
  • And why shouldn't it be... intuition permits all that enter.
  • Naturalistic decision making (Klein 1998) shows that agents within sufficient experience in a given domain make decisions on the basis of a cognitive process other than conscious considerations of various options and the weighing of evidence and utilities. Such expert intuitions appear immediately in consciousness. 
  • Last night I had the opportunity to witness a girl do this very thing. She took tremendous delight in her ability to do so ... I couldn't have been more entertained had it happened to me.
  • The intuitions of philosophy constitute a single epistemic and psychological kind, not the sort noted in the previous paragraph. 
  • Figures... philosophers enjoy complexity.
  • Philosophers equate intuitions with beliefs. David Lewis (1983) writes, “Our ‘intuitions’ are simply opinions; our philosophical theories are the same. Some are commonsensical, some are sophisticated; some are particular, some general; some are more firmly held, some less. But they are all opinions.”
  • Some are bagels, some are parks, some are ... Oh, you get the picture. 
  • Example: S has the intuition that p if and only if S believes that p.
  • Soph thinks that this is funny because Soph believes this is funny.
  • We might be more willing to accept the immediate conscious thoughts (first thoughts, gut reactions) based on ontological parsimonies (KISS or Ockham’s Razor). This indicates a close relationship between the thoughts we consider intuitions and the thoughts we call beliefs. 
  • A thought is like making a friend on the playground, he or she was there first. I remember hearing or expressing this without thinking of the significance of that other than its natural development and my recognition of it. 
  • The belief that p is neither necessary nor sufficient for intuition that p is suggested by conflicts between a person’s beliefs and their intuitions suggests that one can reason one’s way to a satisfactory resolution of a paradox and identified the false proposition, but still holds the intuition of the rejected proposition as true or possibly true, thus plausible or possible by nature. 
  • This only happens if one holds beliefs. I am not burdened by beliefs, so the notion is moot. In other words, I give not a hoot.
  • A variation of this theme is having an intuition that p is while simultaneously rationalizing that p is potentially false or even false. This means that one can have an intuition about the validity of p while simultaneously rationalizing it as false. The thought that follows this, either an acceptance based on uncertainty or the rejection based on evidence, is one belonging to one’s ability to choose the highest probable truth, according to the individual’s subjective perception of reality. 
  • Soph has the intuition of an experience while simultaneously rationalizing that her intuition of this experience is potentially false or even false. Soph cares and does not care about the validity of the experience she intuits and would not rationalize something as false as to make such a claim is to claim that Soph knows, and Soph knows that what she knows she knows and what she does not know she does not know. The thoughts that follow this are mostly about cake and gardens and poetry and philosophical musings and children and baby animals frolicking in the sun at a picnic overlooking a lake lying under a tree on a blanket, surrounded by friends and niceties of all imaginary sorts. This is the highest truth and it is for Soph her own subjective perception of reality, which she enjoys very much. 
  • Finally, one can have a belief without an intuition, such as a belief that the ground is solid when taking a step or a belief that a fact is based on evidence, thus allowing one to consider the belief as a truth claim and thus build additional propositions and/or conclusions. In this sense, one does not have an intuition that p and so belief that p. P is not sufficient for intuition that p. 
  • This is the stuff we take for granted, like 1 + 1 = 2... it is not as much as a belief, as it is an "Okie dokie" ...
  • When viewing a Müller-Lyer illusion one might experience one line as longer than the other, even after repeatedly measuring the lines and thus believing that, according to the measurement tools, they are of equal length. 
  • If the lines do not fit in our subjective house, we exclude them. I fail to see why this is so interesting. Perhaps it is because I prefer to think about the nectar of the gods than to bore my mind with what goes on outside the grounds. Yet, if I were to dream myself into a Müller-Lyer illusion I would indeed walk around and follow the lines and count my steps and feel for myself how the lines fit together. Then on this matter I would have something to say.
  • The doubt that is cast here, favored by many psychologists and philosophers with naturalistic inclinations - myself included in the latter group - is consistent with the thought that intuitions are beliefs with a suitable etiology. (Gopnik and Schwitzgebel 1998; Devit 2006, p. 491; Kornblith 1998). 
  • Okie dokie (see above).
  • My own naturalistic inclinations are perhaps similar to those derived by so-called “physiologists,” like Thales and Anaxagoras, who attempted to explain the origins of the universe and the causes of nature. My continual reference to “energie” as a catch-all term for the multitude of energetic shapes I perceive and have been experimenting with since early childhood arise from this inclination.
  • Water, air, breath, fire, infinite, energie... stuff, God, Allah, Buddha, Krishna... sounds like the making of an indy joke.
  • Soph has the intuition that energie is and can be interpreted as a language or map if and only if Soph forms the occurrent belief that energie exists and can be interpreted as a language or map without consciously inferring it from some other belief. 
  • What Soph said (see above).
  • Or in general terms, S has the intuition that p if and only if S forms the occurrent belief that p without consciously inferring it from some other belief. 
  • Yup.
  • Beliefs with an inferential origin of which a person is conscious are not intuitions. While one might argue that an agent can confuse intuition with a non-inferential perceptual belief, memory belief or introspective belief, those supporting beliefs can still be put to the test by re-examining those beliefs following a new intuitive moment. 
  • 1 + 1 = 2. Check √
  • Rather than believing in an intuition it is possible to hold an intuition as a possible truth claim. In the absence of further etiological restrictions or confirmations, one might employ a skeptical position in that one cannot know from within the system it examines (i.e., the universe or itself). This leaves room for p and not p to coexist. This approach requires reexamination in the face of all new intuitions or information pertaining to a prior intuition and would be exhausting for the less inquisitive mind. 
  • In the absence of further etiological restrictions or confirmations, one might ENJOY the thought and leave skepticism for those who fiddle around with beliefs. Acknowledging something that is is not the same as believing that acknowledgment is anything other than what it is. If told or shown otherwise, the process begins anew. This leaves room for everyone to exist and not exist at the same time. True, it does require reexamination of related thoughts and sensations, but that is the fun in it. Gives us something to do. I recommend plenty of caffeine, sweets, salty foods, loads of water, daily exercise, philosophical ruminations, fanciful imaginings, good company, loving thoughts, suitors, children and little animals, and things to play with or create other things. These things make great props and lovely contributions to living while one dedicates their mind to the aforementioned ruminations. Feel free to substitute everything in this list for stuff you prefer. 
  • (Ludwig, 2007) S has the intuition that p if and only if S forms the occurrent belief that p solely on the basis of competence with the concepts involved in p. 
  • Competence comes from reevaluating things every time new information is presented. Hence the need for caffeine and sweets. This requires a lot of physical energie. Soph is now smiling as her mind combines those two concepts: physical + energie.
  • Recognizably direct introspective judgments regarding intuition are difficult to justify as agents might lack direct introspective access to the non-conscious causes of one’s beliefs. If, however, the existence of p is (i.e., intuitions and non-conscious thoughts) have an etiological origin in the natural energetic material from which matter arises and takes form, then it might be possible to gain a form of access via perception (similar in domain to intuition) from which a clearer pathway might be recognized. 
  • Don't worry if this happens. It is not a big deal. If it becomes a big deal, artefacts of this processing failure will appear in multiple areas of your life, which you'll naturally attend, though perhaps not with the same cheerful attitude you might have had while drinking caffeine, eating sweets, and enjoying your garden to the utmost. My recommendation is to get through it as efficiently as possible, smile along the way (for no reason other than it feels better than not smiling), and celebrate once you've completed each task. 
  • Peter van Inwagen: “in some cases, the tendencies that make certain beliefs attractive to us, that ‘move’ us in the direction of accepting certain propositions without taking us all the way to acceptance (1997, p. 309). This suggests S has the intuition that p if and only if S is disposed to believe p. This disposition to believe is a propositional attitude similar to what might arise after deriving multiple similar conclusionary possibilities following intuitive moments or insights. 
  • This makes perfect sense. It is, at least for me, how my mind processes sensations into thoughts.
  • While some agents might formulate and thus act in accordance with a potential or perceived belief about the validity of a given intuition, this does not indicate an automatic acceptance of that belief insomuch as it prohibits the agent from re-examination should another intuition arise that leads the agent to question either the intuition or the conclusion. 
  • Naturally, this could merely indicate that said person is experimenting with potential thoughts. Experimentation is not a belief in the experiment, it is a "What if" and a willingness to explore. Exploration isn't believing, it is playing. Playing make-believe is an entirely different thing. 
  • To believe on the basis of mere human understanding could also be argued as a belief (such as a belief in the validity of intuition or energie or p) if one holds a skeptical view on the epistemological nature of knowing. Thus, S has the intuition that p if and only if S is [philosophically] disposed to believe p merely on the basis of understanding. S may indeed simultaneously categorize this philosophical disposition as p and thus hold p and not p without conflict between the conscious and non-conscious mind insomuch as both belief and non-belief arise from belief. 
  • What else can we do? It is difficult to conceive of what is not, until we bring it into being. Once we bring it into being, we are back here. Thus, Soph has the intuition that this is true if and only if Soph is disposed to believe she recognizes herself, which one might say is a recognition of self from another self, which brings up a whole host of things we'll not get into for the sake of "brevity" -------> Now that's funny! 
  • The sui generis occurrent propositional attitude, variously characterized as one in which a proposition occurrently seems true (Bealer 1998, 2002; Pust 2000; Huemer 2001, 2005), in which a proposition is presented to the subject as true (Chudnoff 1011a), or which pushes the subject to believe a proposition (Koksvik 2011). These views are united in denying a belief that p is necessary or sufficient for an intuition that p and in rejecting dispositional analyses of intuition adopts a view or belief, either consciously or unconsciously, and thus each intuition or conscious thought cycles through this belief so that the close connection between intuition that p and disposition to believe p is explained by claiming that intuitions can serve as the ground of the disposition to believe p. Example: I sensed a break in energie and thus concluded I should look further for tangible evidence of this perceived break. If this agent does not find tangible evidence to support p (the intuition), then the agent might simultaneously believe p and not p until evidence is found, which can be considered indicative of a belief in and of itself (the continual search based on a deeply held belief) or indicative of a belief in the skeptical notion that we cannot know and thus must continually search until one can validate a truth claim as true or false. 
  • Gee wiz, this was a long one. Did anyone even bother reading this to make it worth my time to think about it? Alas, I shall think about it for the sake of beauty, for the sake of uniformity, for the sake of the thought itself and the true enjoyment I derive from thinking. Okay, here it goes... independent thinkers are cool ... visit a coffee house to witness this phenomenon.  When you arrive to said coffee house, order a beverage and find a good seat. Think about the last time you heard something TOTALLY BOGUS. That feeling you just got, right this very moment, in the pit of your stomach, this is your belief. Now, reconcile the idea that all of your ideas stem from this gut feeling. The way your mind works is the process that occurs as you ruminate, categorize, recognize, epiphanize, or otherwise convince yourself of your next thought. Now think about the thoughts you just thought. What do they have in common? Are they consistent with other thoughts? Are they different? If yes, how so? Now, ask yourself if they are really different? Presuming you have the capacity to ask the last question, you're probably thinking to yourself that they're not all that different. That should tell you something. If you don't know what I'm talking about, start anew and try again. If you do not wish to start anew, sit back and relax and enjoy your beverage. Besides, while you are sitting there kicking back, someone else is busy at work creating new styles, designed to meet our needs and subsequent pleasures many derive from these niceties. While you're hanging out at a Coffee house thinking about stuff, someone else is out there getting rich on an idea you could have had had you been busying yourself thinking about things that other people would buy. Take me for example, I could be thinking about writing a book given how many people ask me to publish. I could write in a website and charge annual subscriptions to read this sometimes delightful nonsensical musings, which are actually quite entertaining. Just ask the author, she totally agrees.... thinks for a moment, and comes to the conclusion that she does not enjoy editing or formatting or work of any nature as it is offensive to her physical system. Thus she just writes for the sheer enjoyment of doing so. She publishes for her children's future amusement when comes the day her particles disburse. She acknowledges that someday said children, you know who you are, might read this in which case she bids you a warm hello while wrapping her arms around you in our favorite ritual: the hug. She also acknowledges that the public reads some this stuff, though she doubts that few are actually reading this particular passage word-for-word. Still, if someone is, hello to you, too. She smiles and moves on.
  • There is also the interpretation or perception of an experience’s categorization. S has the intuition that p if and only if it seems to S that p. In this sense, p is how S has defined it to be categorically, with each category holding truth claims not theretofore compared or contrasted against a given intuition associated with p. If categorical, memorial, or introspective discriminations within propositional context exist, then it is not consistent with intuitions as a separate intelligence from which knowledge might be considered, interpreted, or perceived. This implies the notion of perceptual intuitions. 
  • Soph has the intuition that if she wrote a book few would sell and only if she believed more would sell would Soph bother publishing. In this sense, publishing in a blog is how Soph has been experimenting with writing styles as Soph has no particular burning preference other than to combine letters in celebratory meaning for the sheer delight of being able to do so. If a clear feeling should arise that one particular style of writing would appeal to or be enjoyed by many, Soph would be happy to make one of those books for a book is a piece of art, a leisurely stroll down a parchment or scroll... interestingly enough, Soph just imagined a scroll instead of a book and now has something fun to do today as she has decided to experiment with said presentation. 
  • Clarity is served by stipulating that the author holds the belief that multiple intelligences exist and that they are all species of a common genus, and that genus is intuition, which as a form of intelligence could indeed be measured.
  • On the notion of Clarity: As incoherent and meaningless as this post might be to others, it is an act of clarity to think about one's thinking, to openly express without impediment one's own thoughts. To shield ourselves from our thoughts is an act of treason against oneself, which for me would be an abomination of self...  and Soph likes Soph. Soph would like Soph to loose 10 pounds, but that is because Soph has a highly developed aesthetic side. 
  • Of course there is the intellectual approach, e.g., this written, albeit heuristic in nature, response. In this case, one might say that S has the intuition that p if and only if it intellectually seems to S that p. That sums it up pretty nicely, I believe.
  • I agree with myself. It does sum it up pretty nicely. Besides, what else am I to believe other than those thoughts produced by my own testimony. See The Promise.
  • All joking aside (how funny is this comment), when it comes to intellectual ruminations, they arise from wherever all thought arises, intellectualized in the brain, sensitized in the body, intuited by a sense, a prioried via natural inheritance, or otherwise manifested via some unknown and not yet considered form or system. Where thought in and of itself comes from is not known and not the focus on this response, but for distinction purposes, the explanation is offered both as an acknowledgement that our species does not consciously possess, if possession is possible, a unifying theory or additional knowledge to answer such epistemological or metaphysical questions, and must thusly draw a line between the two potentially distinct thought patterns: intellectual rationalization versus natural intuition. Whether or not the two are separate or of the same source, despite the variance in their characteristics, is unknown and thus acknowledged as such.
  • I think the above paragraph sums it up perfectly and deserves repeating: "Intellectual ruminations arise from wherever all thoughts arise, intellectualized in the brain, sensitized in the body, intuited by a sense, a prioried via natural inheritance, or otherwise manifested via some unknown and not yet considered form or system. Talk about covering all the bases! Perhaps this is as close as I get to holding a belief, for it is my belief that I covered all the bases, though I am not without the subsequent belief that there could be things I have not considered. If said time reveals further thoughts on the matter, I shall reevaluate this and synthesize new information with this. Until said time, I cannot conceive of what is not, until, like I said above, it IS.
  • Presuming rational intuitions and natural intuitions are distinct in characteristic or in nature, the possibility arises for S to have a rational intuition that p IFF it intellectually seems to S that necessarily p. 
  • Just like the girl at the cash register last night. She asked when the transaction took place, I told her about a week before Christmas. She approximated a date and chose the 20th as a starting point. Lo and behold, it was on the 20th. She got it on the first guess! Clever, clever girl who admitted to me that she could do so much more than she was doing to which I immediately and without hesitation agreed before my mind even explored a thought of what that could be as it was apparent in her ability and delight over her ability, perhaps the latter being most prominent as a sign of ability ~ at least in my mind. I wonder what impetus would be needed for her to do something that constitutes "more" in her mind. I shall think on this and see if there isn't something I might do to aide her toward that without giving her anything, which is essentially taking away from her inherent ability to do it for herself. She would recognize such a gift and not delight in it as she delights in that which she conceives and does for herself. Perhaps I shall invite her to tea for a friendly chat and if an opportunity to bring this up arises, we might discuss it and I might again have the privilege of witnessing this quality in herself, which given her mindset, will set off a chain reaction leading to her "doing something more". How nice would that be for her and who knows how many other people. I enjoy the rise of energie wherever it is found. 
  • This renders all rational intuitions overtly modal in context and, on a view of concept possession according to which possessing the concept c at t requires the ability to deploy c in thought at t, requires a level of sophistication not obviously had by the philosophical innocent who is, nonetheless, presumably capable of having a rational intuition (Pust 2000, p. 38; Ludwig 2007, p. 136). 
  • Such is life. It is how many are wired to process thought. If one wishes to think beyond this it is truly for intellectual musings as recreating the thought that allows one to create the wheel is a lot of work and not work that will necessarily yield new thought. Nevertheless, the thoughts that do arise are new for the individual thinker. Thus thinking thoughts that others have thought is indeed an act of thinking a new thought as it is new to the thinker of the thought. I like thinking new thoughts, be them wholly new or not, as they are wholly new for me. If they were thought before, I merely have an allegory for my own thought with which I can play, enhancing my own new thought with delightful tales of the new ones that follow. 
  • With respect to possibility claims it is not known whether they are part of the intuitive process or an inferential based on rational intuition. 
  • This is indeed a good question. I call these things "What ifs" ... what I do about them depends on whether I have the time or am in the mood to experiment... though I rarely EVER give away what the experiment is and admit that what gets recorded is often times a symptom of the experiment not the thought itself... what comes next is anyone's guess, including my own. 
  • In the same respect, one might say that S has the rational intuition that p IFF either [A] (1) it intellectually seems to S that p and (2) if S were to consider whether P is necessarily true, it would intellectually seem to S that necessarily p, or [B] it intellectually seems to S that necessarily p. 
  • Soph has the rational intuition that she is now tired of this exercise AND it seems to Soph that she is not alone in her thinking, though she could be wrong about that, but even if she is, she is tired of this exercise, so there you have it. Nuff said. If she were to continue, she might get into thoughts such as these: 
  • This same distinction, as described in the preceding paragraph, could also be made between philosophical inquiry versus scientific experimentation. Given that there is sufficient information available on this topic, there is no need to elaborate beyond the general inclusion. 
  • This opens up an entire discussion in the field of logic.
  • One more similar in nature modal-like distinction could be made between intellectual or natural inheritance like intuitions and physical, unconscious intuitions. Malcolm Gladwell’s pioneering book Blink offers a compelling explanation for the existence of a physical intuition, which might be connected with general intuition, as described herein. Whether a distinction can be made between physical intuitions and other types of intuitions, general or otherwise, is unknown. As with all possibilities accepted or rejected, this should possibility should be explored further. 
  • This is a hot potato. Add salt and Ketchup and I'm there!




*This post has not been edited. These are random thoughts written down and recorded in the moment directly preceding the spacetime in which they were conceived. Because there is a lot of writing here, Soph, already being reticent to publish merely because she has a distaste for editing and proofing, has decided not to go back and edit, and sends her apologies in advance if this required more "guess work" on behalf of the Reader... though admittedly, "guess work" can be fun as one does not have a specific answer and can play around with one's own thoughts while simultaneously deciding whether one cares enough to seek an answer. 










An Epithalamion

The Lady (2013)
Shenn


An Epithalamion 


Privileged locations
Aesthetic views
Taste for freedom
Refusing submission to rules

Colors in the sky
Tensions in minds
Freshness of the morning
Homage to life

Locus amoenus
Aural sensations
Secluded from the world
Pleasurable libations

A desirable retreat
Cupid and Venus present
Perfect intimacy
Allusions beget

Admiration of charms
A tender entice
Yielding to entreaties
Spirits ignite

A Wooer reassures
Shyness is sweet
Prelude to an afternoon
A fervent plea

Expectations ready
Subtle fusion
Celebrated under an epithalamion
Explosion

Natural pleasures
Impressionist touches
Beauty and virtue
Willing brushes

Tame the waters
Cool the characters
Do not disturb
Ethereal figures

Wild creatures roaming
Symbols of essence
Natural contrasts
Moments of presence

Fecund memories
Reflected in union
Celebrated in an Ode
A poetic communion


இڿڰۣ










Thursday, January 16, 2014

How to Build a Garden

Windblown (2011)
Shenn


When one decides to build a garden or special space for oneself, one's purpose is to create a space that gives one pleasure. First, one chooses a place to build their garden or special space and builds a barrier around it to separate it from the nongarden surrounding it. Next, the gardner or special space seeker selects those elements from nature or from his or her travels, for example, elements that are pleasing, such as fragrant flowers, Picasso sketches, or Chagall paintings. The gardner or special space seeker then arranges these elements within the garden or special space according to a design that is in harmony with the parameters of the space selected and that allow him or her to fully appreciate each element to the fullest. Essentially, a garden or special space is a special space full of lovely curiosities from nature (including those created from human nature) arranged in a pleasing or harmonious way.

After creating one's garden or special space, the gardner or special space creator must maintain the space with utmost vigilance and care. He or she has to discourage the growth of plants that are not harmonious to preserving the beauty he or she has created. Items that are not harmonious with how he or she wishes to feel in this space are not included so as to preserve his or her garden or special space as he or she wishes it to be. 

To preserve this space as the gardner or special space seeker wishes it to be for any significant amount of time, the gardner or special space seeker must actively work in harmony with the space as if that space were a natural occurrence in nature. For nature, when left to her own will, does not concern herself with human nature and will grow over rose or flower beds without concern for them staying put. It is nature's job to grow and when left undirected, will grow in the direction that dictates its trajectory. Wind, temperature, humidity, terrain, and other factors dictate how and in which directions nature progresses. Human beings act as similar agents of change, redirecting flowers to remain put by trimming and pruning them in accordance with their own aesthetic or natural preferences. Just as dust and other elements affect a special space, humans address these agents of change by introducing wood polishes, ionizers, or special lighting so as to preserve the original integrity of a painting or piece of antiquity.

In this respect, gardens and special spaces are temporally crafted spaces. Existing as long as the gardner or special space seeker attends them. While one could say that these spaces would fall into disarray if left unattended, it is of no real consequence for mother nature herself too ceases to exist without agents of change (wind, temperature, humidity, human beings, animals, and so forth). For the time that the gardner or special space seeker has the space to the time that it no longer exists exists moments whereby the garden or space might be appreciated. This appreciation for a temporally crafted garden or special space is not unlike the appreciation one might feel for life. 

Creating gardens and special spaces is not about imposing order, it is about participating in temporal moments of pleasure that enhance how we perceive the gardens and special spaces we create for ourselves. There are no harsh realities of life outside the barriers of our gardens and special spaces, only different realities with different agents of change. While some gardens or spaces, depending on their spacetime location may require more energy or protection from unharmonious elements, their presence in our experience of living is as natural as mother nature herself for we are all elements of change be us human, animal, perceptible natural movements, forces, energy, or otherwise. How we arrange ourselves, how we build our gardens or special spaces, has as much to do with our intentions, form, and function as it does with our resources, imagination, place in the universe, and heartfelt desire for living well. 



Wednesday, January 15, 2014

Misological Missy: Tea and Sparkling Discourse



Most individuals would rather pay someone to read their fortune from tea leaves at the bottom of a cup than engage in a philosophical debate.

    Brewing the perfect cup of tea takes time, just as philosophy is a slow and laborious process. Choosing the perfect tea leaf demands careful examination, while philosophizing demands that we examine each and every thread of reason. 

     Philosophizing requires fastidious, meticulous attention to detail, the ability to search for minor, even trivial errors in how thoughts are sewn together, and the willingness to essentially ask oneself how, where, and if one should be carrying around certain thoughts and ideas in one’s head. 

     The willingness to match philosophical wits against one’s fellow citizen can end in disaster, as it did in the case of the Greek philosopher Socrates (469 - 399 BCE), who, despite devoting his entire life to unraveling the threads of reason, was ultimately given hemlock instead of tea, and put to death for impiety and for corrupting the youth of Athens.

     Perhaps Socrates was a bit “too” Confucius-like in nature, ignoring practical worries such as those associated with husbandry, parenthood, and livelihood. Instead of devoting himself to ordinary pursuits, Socrates could be found cheerfully and leisurely strolling though the Agora, the gathering place in the ancient city of Athens. He discoursed with people of all kinds and classes, from lowest to highest. He joked. He smiled. He made the people whom he questioned and cross-examined feel important, and he always seemed to welcome their answers as a means of learning more about a subject he wished to consider. 

     Had Socrates not been so busy heuristically acquiring knowledge about himself and his fellow, beloved Athenians, he might have instead busied himself crafting clever puzzle boxes to delight - instead of corrupt - Athenian children. 

     Rather than poking holes in the rational judgment of his fellow citizens, he could have harnessed his unique combination of constructive energy and practical dynamism to discuss enigmas and the marvelous ingenuity of others. Rather than pointing out erroneous thoughts, Socrates could have, in the same mood of joyful freedom, spent the entirety of his life teaching Athenians how to play logic games or introducing them to their own, unique brand of brilliance. 

     Had Socrates turned his philosophical quest into a delightful game, he might have emerged the victor, securing himself a lifetime of tea parties and hearty meals at the celebratory table in the Prytaneum, where the victors of the Olympic Games were awarded meals for life.

     Instead of the “Socratic Method”, a form of inquiry and discussion meant to stimulate critical thinking and illuminate ideas, the world might have instead had the “Socratic Puzzle”, an enigma that tests the ingenuity of the solver by requiring them to put together pieces in a logical way in order to come up with a desired solution. 

     Instead of discussing the problems of Athenian government, Socrates could have built board games, the solutions to which would have demanded great skill of its players in recognizing patterns and creating a particular order; skills that Athenian children with higher inductive reasoning and aptitudes might have later put to good use in Athenian government. And who would have been congratulated? Why, their teacher Socrates, of course. And yes, Socrates, being Socrates, may have said that he was not a teacher to be congratulated, but simply a builder of puzzles. 

     As children delight in discovery, so too would their parents have delighted in seeing their offspring put their puzzle solving and critical thinking skills to use to solve serious issues affecting Athens. Whether Socrates wished it or not, he would have been rolling in minas as a result. Aristophanes might have depicted Socrates as an earnest and forthright son of Athens, who climbed a tree, reached up into the clouds, and pulled out a puzzle. 

     “Socrates! Sweet Socrates! Build us a puzzle that we might feel as if we are floating in the clouds after having solved it. Build us a puzzle that might allow us to safely watch an eclipse and contemplate the Sun. And then teach us, O Socrates, how to solve all your puzzles, which we have come to learn.”

     There are many ways to match wits, some clearly more positive than others. Rather than nit-pick, demolish, or leave inconclusive someone’s thoughts, explore them, discover yourself in them, and then allow yourself to linger. Wander through thoughts as if each and every one was a guest at your tea party. Consider each thought on its own merit. Good thoughts will naturally come together like a well-designed puzzle. Bad thoughts don’t naturally fit. You need to turn them around or twist them in some form or fashion, but they belong somewhere or they would not have been invited to the party in the first place. As with all good puzzles and tea parties, the task at hand is to find the solution, to find how or where every one might fit at the table. Every puzzle piece has place and it’s up to us to find it. 

         Every thought that arrives to Misological Missy’s tea party is thought about, and then dipped in tea and enjoyed like a crumpet. 

     And who is at the other end of this Prytaneum table? Why, it is Misological Missy’s good friend, Socrates! 

     Tired of conversing with Orpheus and Musaeus and Hesiod and Homer; having heard all Palamedes and Ajax the son of Telamon had to say; Socrates welcomed his invitation. 

     “What a delight!” said Socrates, at the notion of joining Misological Missy and all the thoughts and figures she invited to her tea party. 

     Squares and rectangles, triangles and parallelograms, even the more unique esoteric shapes and figures presented party guests with a delightful challenge: to make them all fit.

     “And nicely, so!” said Missy. 


Art by Shenn




Tuesday, January 14, 2014

On Justice


Pindar states: 

Can I by justice or by crooked ways of deceit ascend a loftier tower which may be a fortress to me all my days?

The answer to this question concerns the notion of justice. What conclusions are we to draw from the results of leading a just life -vs- an unjust life, and which life, the just one or the unjust one, yields the most pleasurable, worldly outcome? 

This question has plagued the world's inhabitants for centuries. 

Lobby to Main Reading Room. Government mural by Elihu Vedder. 
Library of Congress Thomas Jefferson Building, Washington, D.C.


Is there profit to be found in being good... in being just... in philanthropic or benevolent pursuits? What if one puts these pursuits over their own well-being? Is the act of putting one's own well-being above philanthropic gestures a selfish act, or is it merely as aspect of living well, such as putting on one's own mask prior to helping another? 



In theorizing whether one reaches a loftier, more pleasurable state of living by being just or unjust in their actions, I must invariably draw from my own life choices if I wish to find a clearer understanding of how I perceive and respond to both concepts ~ justice and injustice ~ and how those concepts affect my thoughts, and most importantly, my behavior and actions. 

To claim that a person is just or unjust is to assume that we have insight into their personal, subjective personhood. Rather than assume this is possible, I find it easier to simply comment on an individual person's behavior or actions, or lack thereof, when describing the nature of justice. 

If we relate justice to consequences, such as positive or negative ones associated with helping someone when there is no personal benefit to do so, we reduce justice to an expenditure of time, effort, or resources. 

No wonder people question the nature of justice. 



The world in which we live is dictated largely in part by the resources at our disposal. Most everyone has a specific way or manner about them, a potential that can be harnessed into a resource, but not everyone is equally distributed with the resources that would more easily yield a healthy, productive world citizen who possesses knowledge of themselves, knowledge of the world, and has the capacity to utilize their resources in a way that improves or beautifies the environment we all inhabit. 

Sometimes a person is of low intelligence or low drive and lacks an interest in contributing to the common good, sometimes a person has a high intelligence and high energetic drive, but lacks the financial resources to contribute to the common good, and the maldistribution continues. 



Given that resources are not equally distributed among all the world's inhabitants, one must take what they are given and do their best to achieve a state of equilibrium, in terms of meeting their physical needs, before endeavoring to help others. 

Of course, there are those who do not have all of their physical needs met, and might even be homeless, and yet they find a way to write or create something meaningful for others that instantly improves their financial or physical circumstances. While the latter example does happen, it is not always the norm. 



It is to the norm that we look when it comes to expounding on whether justice vs injustice serves a better means to achieve worldly success (and maybe even happiness). As the examples above indicate, there are an endless number of examples on how resources are and are not distributed equally among people, thus I return to my own life for study and reflection. 

Not being born into a life of Royal obligations, into a life of global philanthropic concerns, or into a life of cultural understanding beyond what personal preferences my family held on the subject cultural contribution, my early life could be described as provincial. How my interests grew in complexity is in part due to sheer luck as well as to the resources I did possess, which was an inheritance of physical allure, what was described to me as a regal presence, an affable, good-natured disposition, and a quickness of wit and intellect that allowed me to maintain volumes of information in my working memory whilst simultaneously being able to draw upon deeper, more philosophical considerations that, for better or worse, made me and others around me think twice about their thoughts and actions. 

While not possessing an abundance of worldly resources upon which to embark a lifetime of experiences, I did possess the above-mentioned natural resources that, once out in the world, enabled me to support myself and others, as well as learn and grow and reach toward greater heights as a result. Given enough time, these results were exponential in their growth to the point that questions of justice and injustice came into my conscious awareness. 



My family might tell you that I exercised a number of philanthropic-minded gestures throughout childhood and young adulthood, but in my mind, beyond building companies and offering employment to those seeking it, my first truly philanthropic gesture was directed toward the inhabitants of a very poor, desolate region in the middle of the Mexican desert, a place through which I drove returning from a shopping trip in the United States. 

As we drove along the freeway, I noticed people out begging along the roadside. At the time I didn't understand why they were out "in the middle of nowhere" and was told that they lived in the mountains and came down to the roadside in the winter to beg for food. 

The moment I heard this my heart sank and I asked the driver to pull over so I could give them some food and extra clothing. I was nearly ripped from the car and we had to speed off for our own protection, not because they wished to hurt me, but because they were so very desperate for resources.

Immediately upon returning to Mexico City, with the aid of some generous friends, we arranged for a delivery truck to return with food, blankets, and toys for the kids. Each year thereafter we sent a truck with much-needed supplies.



These actions might be considered generous, but are they just? What is just about leaving these people out in this barren region to fend for themselves? What is just about some individuals having more resources than others? 

Justice seems to me like a manmade concept more than a natural one. If justice were natural, we would all be endowed with the same level of physical beauty, the same strength and physical stamina, the same talents and abilities, and the same cognitive abilities to help us circumvent life's challenges. 

Promoting justice is a bit Robinhoodish, taking from the rich to give to the poor. Whether or not the poor are deserving beyond their being poor is an entirely different matter. 



When it comes right down to it, most of us would much rather do the giving than the receiving, which perhaps is nature's way of correcting injustice. 


Returning full-circle to the question of whether or not it is better to live an unjust life, taking or keeping for oneself as many resources as possible so that one might erect an Ivory Tower for oneself, or whether it is best to redistribute those resources among our fellow citizens is perhaps a matter of preference. 

Drawing from my own life, in which I have chosen the latter, I can only say that while it feels wonderful to feast, it doesn't feel right to feast alone. 


Perhaps that is what Marie-Antoinette meant when she was misquoted as saying, "Let them eat cake". Perhaps she merely wished for everyone to join her in enjoying cake and was not as informed as she could have been about the state of affairs in France given that she had grown up in an Ivory Tower. When you don't go outside, you don't really know what's going on... and can only trust that those who are supposed to manage such things are doing so for the benefit of all the nation's citizens. Had she known they did not have bread, she would have shared her cake without hesitation. Not out of a sense of justice, but from the generosity of heart that is required to combat injustice. 


இڿڰۣ
















Sunday, January 12, 2014

Finding Authenticity in Becoming



Most of us have a shared taste for authenticity, for freedom of expression and for finding new ways to allow our inner self and emotions to come through. 

Belonging to our sense of taste and values is the passionate interest for authenticity as it is perceived in settings of our own fanciful imaginings. The power of emotions and passions felt in such privileged locations illustrate this taste and preference. 



In authentic happenings, life triumphs over repose: the world is awake in its pantheistic view of itself. 



Whether one has a preference for the quiet moment of a morning spent in the presence of self or for a moment shared with others, each and every moment in which we find ourselves is our authentic self in that given moment. The homage we pay to past moments or importance we place on future moments are all held in A moment. This moment is different from this moment and yet they are all moments. As with being, I am me here, and there, and everywhere I go, even though I am a different version of me here, there, and everywhere I go.



Authentically being is as redundant as saying I exist in existence. Authenticity is a matter pertaining to judgment and values. If I like truly enjoy or connect to this moment, I am being my authentic self. If I do not enjoy this moment and wish to connect to a different moment, I am also being my authentic self in my preference and taste for specific moments of being (authentic or otherwise nonexisting).



Perhaps it is not a matter of authenticity for We are what we are (cue Popeye) in every given moment, thus the need for authenticity is as redundant as we are that which we are (as well as that which we seek, though admittedly this is a matter of debate).



I am as authentically me as you are authentically you. I am "me" and you are "you" and perhaps like the fleeting but highly complex trajectories taken by snowflakes on their maiden journey into ever-becoming, we are but the stuff snowflakes (and dreams) are made *of.

Giorgio de Chirico


"The dream is a little hidden door in the innermost and most secret recesses of the soul, opening into that cosmic night which was psyche long before there was any ego-consciousness, and which will remain psyche no matter how far our ego-consciousness may extend. For all ego-consciousness is isolated: it separates and discriminates, knows only particulars, and sees only what can be related to the ego. Its essence is limitation, though it reach to the farthest nebulae among the stars. All consciousness separates; but in dreams we put on the likeness of that more universal, truer, more eternal man dwelling in the darkness of primordial night. There he is still the whole, and the whole is in him, indistinguishable from nature and bare of all egohood ... It is from these all-uniting depths that the dream arises, be it ever so childish, grotesque, and immoral. So flowerlike is it in its candor and veracity that it makes us blush for the deceitfulness of our lives." (C.G. Jung, "The Meaning of Psychology for Modern Man" in CW X, par. 304-5)




A dream:

"I'm standing outside on a grassy, gently sloping field. In front of me, slightly higher to the right, a round silver ring hangs in the sky. Floating outward from the ring are 4 pieces of blue, faded slik. I can still see some faded Chinese-looking lettering on it. This is a THESIS. I know with certainty that whatever question it is asked, it will always reply with the only one possible true answer." 


lol












 *until we are something else, somewhere or somewhen else.

Friday, January 10, 2014

On Knowledge



In the sense that knowledge is ever-changing... it is inexpressible and transcendental. 

Knowledge so far as it springs from the desire to know something about the ultimate meaning of life, the absolute, can be no science. What we discover does not add to our knowledge as knowledge is an ever-changing state of temporal perception held in the notion of understanding. 

Still, the act of learning is a tendency of the human mind which I personally cannot help respecting deeply and I would not for my life ridicule it. 


Admiration (1897)
William-Adolphe Bouguereau (1825-1905)
San Antonio Museum of Art



While these words echo Wittgenstein's argument on ethics [Notebooks 1914-1916, ed. G.H. von Wright and G.E.M. Anscombe (Oxford: Blackwell, 1979), p. 79; Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus (London: Routledge, 1981), pp. 182-183: 6.421], they equally express the issue of not-knowing. 

Knowing touches the part of us that believes It is alive. That aspect of self that knows it exists. Learning is what happens after some 'thing' stirs us from the inside out. Knowledge is that which we believe we find. 

A Reader recently commented, 



To have knowledge, as with the notion of the "Perfect Me", is to be in possession of a divine afflatus. 

In more modern terms, it is the sensation of being blown away by one's own insight or belief in a private revelation about the nature of existence. 

This knowledge is found in the penultimate thought: 


"I know that I do not know"


...and arises within us an intense sense of enjoyment, a heightened interest in experiencing further insights, and a profound and deeply personal sense of approval of one's self, whatever form that self might at present time occupy. 

Ancient or modern knowledge aside, learning is always a value for life, and the discovery that value is always an object of mind.